Is It Bad To Cancel A Credit Card?

Casavvy is part of an affiliate sales network and receives compensation for sending traffic to partner sites, such as   This compensation may impact how and where links appear on this site.  This site does not include all financial companies or all available financial offers. The content on this page is accurate as of the date of posting. Some offers may have changed or expired. 

Many people have unused credit cards sitting in their desk drawer that they don’t use anymore, and they probably wonder about canceling them but never do. Those same people probably of wonder is it bad to cancel a credit card? We are going to give you some good reason why you should cancel them, and some reasons why you might want to leave them open.


Some good reasons to cancel credit cards are: to to be more organized and consolidate accounts that you have open, avoid being tempted to use these cards in the future, or cancel them so that no one can find them and use them fraudulently. If you are working on increasing your credit score, or will be filling out an application for something that involves checking your credit score, you may want to leave them open. But, before you make any decision, there are a couple things you need to go over first.


Tip: A Balance Transfer Credit Card Can Save a Lot of Money When Consolidating Credit Card Balances.


What to Do With Unused Credit Card Accounts

The first thing you need to do is insure that none of these cards have a balance on them. If they do, and you have been missing payments, then you need to pay them off immediately. That whole time you have been incurring interest charges and doing damage to your credit score. After you have paid it off you can put it aside so you know that the card has no balance on it and to stay organized. Now that you know that you have all of your unused credit cards paid off and that there is no balance left on them, you need to make sure that none of these cards have an annual fee associated with them. Even though you are not using a credit card, you will be charged an annual fee if it has one. And this annual fee usually gets charged to the credit card, which will then cause the card to have a balance on it, therefore leading to a payment you need to make.

Next comes the decision about canceling credit cards, or to just leave them open and dormant. The main factor that comes into this decision is the effect that canceling these accounts will have on your credit score. Determining this can be confusing and it is hard to figure out the exact impact it will have on your score, but we will try and make it easy. 15% of your credit score is based on the length of your credit history. This is composed of when you opened your first line of credit (your first credit card, a mortgage, car payment etc.) and also the average of all of your credit lines combined. So if you do not want to have a big impact on your credit score, you will want to leave your oldest unused credit cards open. A good solution is just to cut the credit card up therefore you wont be tempted to use it and you will still get credit for the length of your credit history with that card. If you want to go ahead and cancel some of the newer unused credit cards then your credit score will take a move downward at first. But, if you are responsible and always pay off your current debts punctually, then over time you will see your credit score increase back to what it was (or better). Remember, the only time that your credit score will have an effect on you is when you are taking out a new line of credit. So if you know that you are not going to be getting a new credit card or taking out a loan in the near future, then that is a good time to go ahead and cancel the credit cards you want.

Your Credit Utilization Factor

The next factor is what you need to consider most before closing out your unused credit cards. 30% of your credit score is based on “amounts owed” and part of this component is your credit utilization ratio. This is the total amount of your entire current credit card balances put together, compared to your total credit limit. So if you have 2 credit cards with a $5,000 limit on both of them you have a total credit limit of $10,000. Therefore if, with these 2 cards combined, you have a total balance owed of $3,000, your credit utilization ratio would be 30%. Remember, your unused credit cards are counting towards your total credit limit, so if you decide to cancel one (or more) of them, your credit utilization ratio will go down depending on how much money you owe on your current credit cards. The best place for your credit utilization ratio to be is around 30% or less. So if you can cancel some of your unused credit cards and still stay around this range, then you will be ok and it wont have that adverse of an effect on your credit score. If you cancel 3 or 4 of you unused credit cards and it causes your credit utilization ratio to jump to 80% then you should leave these accounts open and work on paying off your current credit card balances, or ask your current credit card issuer for an increase in your credit limit.

Why to or Why Not to Cancel Your Unused Credit Cards

Everyone wants to be more organized and make life simpler. So if closing credit card accounts will help, then take the previous factors into consider and find out what the best decision will be. Your credit score determines a lot of things and the higher it is, the more options you will have when taking out lines of credit, or loans in the future. Have a good to excellent credit score can also save you a lot of money in the long run as well.